Choose Defense Attorneys

DNA, Scientific Evidence & Forensics

Home » Criminal Law » DNA, Scientific Evidence & Forensics
Choose A Defense Team With The Experience To Make The Right Moves

The Role of DNA, Scientific Evidence, and Forensics in Illinois Criminal Cases

The police and prosecutors often present DNA samples and other forensic evidence as undeniable proof of a defendant’s guilt. But forensic science isn’t always as reliable as it seems. The police and forensic investigators can (and often do) make mistakes while collecting, handling, storing, or interpreting evidence. Those mistakes can change the outcome of a case, which is why it’s vital to have a defense team that understands how to scrutinize this kind of evidence.

At the Law Office of Stephen L. Richards, our attorneys work closely with experienced investigators and expert witnesses to identify flaws in the prosecution’s case. Our Chicago defense lawyers have over 50 years of combined experience and a proven record of successfully defending clients against high-level felonies, including murder charges. Additionally, firm partner Joshua S.M. Richards holds a Bachelor of Science degree in mechanical engineering, giving us a deeper understanding of complex technical issues involving DNA analysis, ballistics, trace evidence, and more. When the prosecution leans heavily on science, we know how to push back with facts, not assumptions.

Choose a defense team with the experience to make the right moves. Call the Law Office of Stephen L. Richards now or complete our contact form for a consultation.

Common Types of Scientific Evidence in Criminal Cases, and How Law Enforcement Uses Them

As law enforcement agencies have gained access to new technology and eyewitness testimony has come under increased scrutiny, the police and prosecutors have increasingly turned to DNA and other scientific evidence to secure convictions. They often portray scientific findings as infallible, which can be persuasive to juries if the defense can’t mount a compelling counterargument. Here are some common types of scientific evidence in criminal cases, along with how the police and prosecutors often use them:
  • DNA Evidence – DNA is the genetic material found in almost every cell of the human body. Law enforcement can collect DNA from blood, hair, saliva, skin cells, or other biological material from the crime scene or, in some cases, from a victim’s body. Prosecutors often use DNA to try to place a suspect at the scene of a crime, link them to a weapon, or connect them to a victim.
  • Fingerprints – Investigators often collect fingerprints lifted from surfaces like doors, weapons, or glass and compare what they find to a suspect’s known prints. A match may suggest that the suspect touched an object or was present at the crime scene.
  • Ballistics – Ballistic analysis involves analyzing bullets, shell casings, or a firearm’s markings to connect a specific weapon to a shooting. Authorities may use this evidence to argue that the suspect fired the gun or possessed it during the crime.
  • Gunshot Residue (GSR) – GSR testing detects tiny particles left on a person’s hands, clothing, or other surfaces after firing a gun. The police or prosecutors often use a positive result to suggest that a suspect recently discharged a gun.
  • Blood Spatter Analysis – Blood spatter analysis involves studying the size, shape, and location of bloodstains to determine how an injury occurred. Analysts use these patterns to estimate the position of the victim and attacker, the type of weapon involved, and the force of impact. The police and prosecutors often use blood spatter findings to build case timelines, reconstruct people’s movements, and strengthen their theory of how the crime unfolded. For example, if someone claims a stabbing happened in self-defense, but the blood pattern shows the victim was lying down during the attack, prosecutors may argue that the evidence contradicts the suspect’s story.
  • Toxicology Reports – Toxicology testing can identify drugs, alcohol, or poisons in blood, urine, or tissue samples. Prosecutors may use this evidence to suggest impairment, motive, or a cause of death in cases involving drunk driving, overdoses, or poisoning.
  • Digital Forensics – With help from modern software, investigators can extract data from phones, computers, GPS systems, and other electronic devices. The authorities often use this information to track a suspect’s movements, uncover their private communications, or place someone near a crime scene. For example, cellphone location data can suggest that a suspect was at or near the scene of a crime.
  • Trace Evidence – Small materials such as fibers, hairs, soil, glass, or paint can be transferred between people, objects, or places. Law enforcement often uses trace evidence to argue that a suspect came into contact with the victim or was present at the scene.
  • Tool Mark and Shoeprint Analysis – Investigators can compare tool marks and shoeprints left at a crime scene to items linked to a suspect. They may use a match to place someone at the scene or tie them to a break-in or assault.

How Forensic Evidence Errors Happen in Criminal Cases

The primary issue with forensic evidence is that criminal investigations don’t happen in a vacuum. People collect this evidence, analyze it, and interpret it, and they can make mistakes or let their biases influence their findings. Some ways that errors can happen when the authorities collect or analyze forensic evidence include:

  • Contamination at the Crime Scene – Police officers or first responders may touch evidence without gloves, mix up samples, or store items improperly, leading to contamination that can skew DNA or trace evidence results.
  • Improper Collection or Storage – Biological samples like blood or saliva can degrade if they’re not collected and preserved correctly. Poor labeling or packaging can also cause sample mix-ups later.
  • Lab Errors and Human Mistakes – Forensic technicians can make errors in testing, especially when they’re under pressure to process evidence quickly. Common mistakes include using outdated testing methods, misinterpreting results, or failing to follow proper lab procedures.
  • Cross-Contamination Between Samples – When investigators test multiple items simultaneously, labs risk contaminating one sample with another, especially if they don’t clean equipment properly or strictly follow testing protocols.
  • Biased or Inaccurate Testimony – Forensic experts may exaggerate the reliability of results in court, making inconclusive findings sound definitive. This practice can mislead juries and unfairly influence verdicts.

Countering False or Misleading Forensic Evidence

Challenging forensic evidence requires a deep understanding of how the authorities collected, tested, and presented that evidence. Our experienced defense attorneys often work with trained investigators and independent experts to review every step of the process.

That analysis starts with examining the crime scene procedures. Did the police and forensic analysts wear gloves? Did they properly label and store evidence properly labeled and stored? If there’s any indication that DNA or other materials were mishandled, we can file motions to suppress the evidence or argue that it’s unreliable.

We also review lab reports and testing methods in detail to look for errors or bias. If technicians used outdated techniques, failed to follow proper protocols, or overstated their findings, we can bring in independent experts to break down their mistakes for the court. For example, if a forensic analyst claims a “match” on a partial DNA profile, we can question the statistical basis for that claim and explain the limitations to a jury. In cases involving ballistics or trace evidence, we may recreate tests or demonstrate how the prosecution’s conclusions rely on shaky assumptions.

Contact Our Chicago Criminal Defense Lawyers Now for Legal Assistance

At the Law Office of Stephen L. Richards, we understand how the authorities use forensic evidence to build their cases and, more importantly, how to point out mistakes in forensic analysis. Firm partner Joshua S.M. Richards’s engineering background helps him understand and point out technical errors in forensic analysis, and we can bring in other experts to show how the evidence against you may be misleading.

Choose a defense team with the experience to make the right moves. Call us now or complete our contact form for a consultation.